Should the state be able to access citizens' data for security?
Side one
Security needs data
Terrorism and crime use digital tools. Access to data helps prevent harm.
Hobbes: Order and the State · Kautilya: The Arthashastra · SuperforecastingSide two
Privacy is a right
Mass surveillance chills free speech and invites abuse.
Locke: Rights and Consent · On Liberty · Hannah Arendt: Thinking and ResponsibilityCommon ground
Both want safety and trust.
How to reconcile them
Allow targeted access under judicial warrant, with strong data protection and oversight.
When each side is right
Stress security for specific threats. Stress privacy for bulk collection and dissent.
Which side are you on?Vote in the app, see what others picked, and explore the debate with AI.
Open in the app